whfick@ksu.edu, Tags:  Bull thistle is erect, 2 to 5 feet tall with many spreading branches, spiny wings from leaves. Musk thistle has been reported in nearly every county in Kansas (Figure 1) and is found primarily in pastures, rangeland, hay meadows, alfalfa, fallow, roadsides, and waste areas. Winter annual plants will germinate with moisture and warm temperatures in the fall, live through the winter, and bolt the following year. Three to five spines occur … Musk Thistle is a very aggressive weed that has increasingly started to invade pastures and rapidly decrease the grazing areas for livestock. All leaves are dark green in color with light green to white midribs and veins. As the adults feed, the females mate and start laying eggs as the thistle begins to bloom. Data presented in Table 1 were collected in July 2013 following treatment on December 6, 2012. One female … Fall is an excellent time to spray musk thistle as all are in the rosette stage of growth. Most people recognize musk thistle during the early summer when the plants are actively blooming (Figure 2, top photo). Musk thistle control with herbicides applied on December 6, 2012. If you need to treat musk thistle this fall, herbicides exist that will not only control the rosettes at the time of application, but will carryover and control new emerging rosettes next spring. During the rosette stage (either fall or spring), musk thistle is most susceptible to chemical control. This … Emerging larvae burrow their way into the crown of the plant where they feed, causing damage to the growing point of the plant (Figure 9). A musk thistle rosette is a cluster of leaves in circular form that grows flat on the ground without an upright stem (Figure 2). This probably means in the fall (late October) or spring (mid April). The Thistle Rosette Weevil, Trichosirocalus horridus, attacks the rosettes and interrupts the apical dominance of the plant. In its second year of growth, the musk thistle plant will leave the rosette … In its second year of growth, the musk thistle plant will leave the rosette … Musk thistle forms a rosette the first year and then bolts the second year to produce flowering stalks and has a taproot. It invades many types of habitats but is a serious threat to pastures as it is unpalatable to livestock. Seeds develop shortly after flowers emerge. The rosette overwinters and the cold causes the rosette to bolt the next season and produce seed. Musk thistle over-winters as rosette. Plants are usually two to six feet tall or taller. After seed germination, the plant develops a fleshy taproot with a rosette of leaves. Fall is the preferred time for applying herbicides to biennial thistles, such as musk thistle and bull thistle. However, musk thistle control is easiest as a rosette (Figure 2, bottom photo). This habit favors attack by R. conicus.. Larvae complete their development then leave the rosette and pupate in the soil. Adjuvants and the Power of the Spray Droplet in Pest Control - Fred Whitford - NNTC 2016 Presentation - MP3 Download, Preparing For The Uncertain Future: Advantages Of No-Till In Extreme Weather (NNTC 2013 Presentation) - MP3 Download, Conquering Slugs In No-Till By Thinking Like A Slug - John Tooker - NNTC 2015 Presentation - MP3 Download, [Webinar] Digging into Soil Health: The Role of Soil Microbes, 5 No-Till ‘Tools’ to be Thankful For in 2020, Extending the Life of Applied Nutrients with a Better Biological Habitat, What I've Learned from No-Tilling: Keeping on an Even, Reliable Keel with Decades of No-Till. Considering how widespread "rhinos" are, this weevil is clearly the best choice for musk thistle control. Just one good idea will pay for your subscription hundreds of times over. Musk thistle has sharply spiny stems and leaves. Musk thistle flower with large brown bracts and the tendency to nod or lean because of the large size of the flower. The leaves are dark green, coarsely bipinnately lobed, with a smooth, waxy surface and sharp yellow-brown to whitish spines at the tips of the lobes. Once the plant puts on seed it will die and that seed spreads by wind. Musk thistle (Carduus nutans) is one of 12 state-wide noxious weeds in Kansas infesting over 700,000 acres. Seedlings emerge in mid to late July and develop into a rosette where plants can reach 4 feet in diameter. These products are all labelled for use on range and pasture. Numerous flower heads are produced from May to October, depending on the species. Musk thistle overwinters as rosette. Numerous flower heads are produced from May to October, depending on the species. Musk thistle generally invades areas that are especially dry and overgrazed. Skies were overcast and cloudy. Freezing temperatures will start to damage musk thistle plants, with some yellowing and curling of leaves. The only treatment not providing nearly 100% residual control was 2,4-D LVE applied at 64 fl oz per acre. Bull thistle generally is the least serious of the noxious thistles. Freezing temperatures will start to damage musk thistle plants, with some yellowing and curling of leaves. Musk thistle is usually a biennial, requiring 2 years to complete a reproductive cycle, but may germinate and flower in a single year in warmer climates. Tordon 22K contains 2 lbs per gallon picloram. All treatments provided excellent control of rosettes present at the time of spraying (data not shown). Focusing on Smarter, Sustainable Fertilizing Strategies, Managing Prevented Planting Acres, Disaster Aid. A bolted plant is one that has developed an upright stem (Figure 3). Musk thistle produces many flower heads. By law, herbicides may only be applied according to label directions.Due to its low cost, 2,4-D ester at 2-4 lb per acre (4.48 kg per half-acre) is the most commonly used herbicide. Bull thistle basal rosette, the first several leaves are not as deeply lobed as leaves that develop later. Another weevil introduced for musk thistle control is Trichosirocalus horridus, which feeds on the apical meristem of the thistle rosette and developing stems. Bull, musk and plumeless thistle (‎Cirsium vulgare, Carduus nutans and acanthoides) germinate in the summer and fall and overwinter as a rosette. Musk thistle is also sometimes called "nodding thistle" because the flower heads can droop to a 90 degree angle instead of facing toward the sky. General. Musk thistle is a biennial weed that reproduces only from seed. The adults are slender and brown with scattered golden spots on the wing covers (Figure 3). Prevention of this plant's invasion is the best form of management. Purple flowers are the identifying factor among the three species. Musk thistle overwinters as rosette. Musk thistle (also known as nodding thistle) overwinters in the rosette stage, four to eighteen inches wide. Flower head weevils lay eggs on the bracts of devel-oping flowers (Figure 7) and cover each egg with a secre- tion of chewed plant material. Although both weevils have been successful, establishment may take several years, thistle … Fall is an excellent time to spray musk thistle as all are in the rosette stage of growth. Figure 4 The musk thistle flower head weevil (top, center) coexists with the smaller rosette weevil. The younger the rosette, the more susceptible it is to the herbicide. When trying to control biennial thistles, destruction of rosettes … 1. Musk thistle in flowering and rosette stages of growth. Flower heads of bull thistle are smaller than musk thistle. Fall is an excellent time to spray musk thistle as all are in the rosette stage of growth. Plants are usually two to six feet tall or taller. Musk thistle forms a rosette the first year and then bolts the second year to produce flowering stalks and has a taproot. Conditions at the time of treatment were 50 degrees F air temperature, 66% relative humidity, and 6-8 mph wind speed. Musk Thistle seedling having a flat growing rosette (photo courtesy of Pamela Borden Trewatha) Another thistle to look out for is Canada thistle. The second year it bolts and sends up a tall flowering stalk with many purple flower heads. Waiting until most deciduous trees have lost their leaves and most crops are harvested will greatly reduce the likelihood of damage from herbicide drift. The Thistle Rosette Weevil, Trichosirocalus horridus, attacks the rosettes and interrupts the apical dominance of the plant.Females often lay over 2000 eggs with the subsequent larval feeding stimulating the plant to form a multi-branched growth habit. The co-chair of the Dodge County Farmers for Healthy Soil & Healthy Water talks about strip-cropping and interseeding cover crops at a field day in the summer of 2020. Opensight was not included in this test, but is a product similar to Chaparral that can be used on non-cropland sites. Musk thistle rosette infested with rosette weevil larvae. In its second year of growth, the Musk thistle plant will leave the rosette stage as its stem elongates (bolts) toward the mature, flowering plant with a large fleshy taproot that is corky and hollow near the ground surface. Download these helpful knowledge building tools, Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing. Seedlings may emerge at any time from spring to late summer and develop a rosette. Another advantage for treatment in the fall is reduced risk of off-target drift. For musk thistle on severely disturbed sites, apply of 2, 4-D ester or dicamba in early bolting phase. Milestone, 2,4-D, and Tordon 22K are also labeled for use on non-cropland sites including roadsides, right-of-ways, and industrial sites. Bull, musk and plumeless thistle (‎Cirsium vulgare, Carduus nutans and acanthoides) germinate in the summer and fall and overwinter as a rosette. The number of rosettes on untreated plots increased 92% between December 2012 and July 2013, indicating spring germination. Musk thistle is a biennial thistle that is a rosette of leaves in its first year and sends up a flowering stalk in its second year, then dies. It invades many types of habitats but is a serious threat to pastures as it is unpalatable to livestock. Figure 9. The data in this table reflect residual control of rosettes that germinated during spring 2013. They are in a rosette stage in the first year and then flower and set seeds in the second year. Musk thistle plants with flower stalks are more difficult to kill than the rosettes. Leaves extend down the stem giving them a … Plants overwinter in the rosette stage, sending up a multi-branched flowering stem in mid spring of their second year. By mid to late May the plants bolt (sending up flowering stems) and soon after bloom. Apply when musk thistle is in the rosette stage, but before the diameter of the rosette exceeds 3 inches. Flowering and seed … However, musk thistle control is easiest as a rosette (Figure 2, bottom photo). Capturing sunlight and keeping living roots in the ground as long as possible is the goal of Beaver Dam, Ws., no-tiller Marty Weiss. Needham Ag understands the role of technology in making better use of limited resources within a specific environment by drawing on a wealth of global experience to overcome the challenges facing today's farmers, manufacturers and dealers. During the rosette stage (either fall or spring), musk thistle is most susceptible to chemical control. Economic damage. This allows for application at the rosette stage, … musk thistle control. However, the plants are susceptible to herbicides as long as green tissue exists. Aminopyralid: Action like indole acetic acid (synthetic auxins) *Milestone 3 - 5 ounces Apply in the spring and early summer to rosette or bolting plants or in the fall to seedlings and rosettes. Musk thistle is one of 12 state-wide noxious weeds in Kansas infesting over 700,000 acres. Multiple seed heads develop from individual plants. Musk thistle is primarily a biennial or winter annual species. Dry conditions in the fall can reduce control of musk thistle with certain herbicides, but studies in Kansas indicated that a fall application of 2,4-D LVE at 2 lbs per acre was more effective (80% control) than a similar rate of 2,4-D amine (49% control). During the rosette stage (either fall or spring), musk thistle is most susceptible to chemical control. Fall is an excellent time to spray musk thistle as all are in the rosette … The plant forms basal rosettes during its first year, which … A wider window of opportunity for treating musk thistle also exists in the fall. Apply Escort or Telar up to the early flower growth stage. The following spring, biennial thistles resume vegetative growth, bolt and then flower. Figure 5 Musk thistle dominated this field, left, in 1975, before introduction of the flower head weevil. Flowering and seed production can start 45 to 55 days after bolting. Tweet The only treatment not providing nearly 100% residual control was 2,4-D LVE applied at 64 fl oz per acre. Chaparral contains aminopyralid and metsulfuron. Canada thistle response to fire has been erratic, with infestations sometimes reduced or occasionally enhanced by fire. musk thistle noxious weed, Copyright © 2019 Department of Agronomy, Kansas State University. A musk thistle seedling has a flat growing rosette. Musk thistle forms a rosette the first year and then bolts the second year to produce flowering stalks and has a taproot. Email. Another advantage for treatment in the fall is reduced risk of off-target drift. 3. Musk thistle rosette –notice white border on leaves Scotch thistle flower Scotch thistle infestation – 2 to 10 feet tall Scotch thistle rosette – notice the fuzzy hairs Canada thistle flower Canada thistle infestation – 1 to 4 feet tall Canada thistle rosette – smaller in size. Waiting until most deciduous trees have lost their leaves and most crops are harvested will greatly reduce the likelihood of damage from herbicide drift. Tordon 22K contains 2 lbs per gallon picloram. Beck Subject: Musk thistle is a biennial weed that reproduces only from seed. Another advantage for treatment in the fall is reduced risk of off-target drift. Whenever it is clipped or mowed it quickly regrows new flowers.… Get full access NOW to the most comprehensive, powerful and easy-to-use online resource for no-tillage practices. 2. Musk Thistle. Thistles that germinate in the spring will spend the entire summer as a rosette, live through the winter, and bolt the next year in May and June. Reproduction is usually via out-crossing through insect pollination, but self-pollination also occurs. If possible, select a warm, sunny day when spraying musk thistle this fall. However, musk thistle control is easiest as a rosette (Figure 2, bottom photo). 1. Apply herbicides such as Tordon, Vanquish/Clarity or 2,4-D to musk thistle rosettes … Apply herbicides such as Tordon, Milestone, Transline, Perspective, Vanquish/Clarity or 2,4-D to musk thistle rosettes in spring or fall. Most people recognize musk thistle during the early summer when the plants are actively blooming (Figure 2, top photo). than 90 percent control of musk thistle rosettes when treated in the spring (Table I). Biennial (short-lived perennial) Family: Sunflower (Asteraceae) Herbaceous; Rosettes … Musk thistle is a biennial thistle that is a rosette of leaves in its first year and sends up a flowering stalk in its second year, then dies. Combine control methods into a management system for best results.Musk thistle is a… Rosette formed first year; flowering stem el… Musk thistle is primarily a biennial or winter annual species. It occurs in all 48 contiguous states and most of Canada, but is designated noxious in only four states. Map courtesy of the Kansas Department of Agriculture. The typical musk thistle exhibits itself first in the form of a rosette, a cluster of tightly packed leaves laying flat on the ground which vary in diameter from a few inches to three feet. Biennial thistles spread only by seed (achenes) that are produced in great number by all the noxious species, ran… Musk … By 1985 the field was nearly clear of musk thistle. 5 Pillars for No-Till Farming Effectively, Efficiently, Making the Precision Basics Even Better with Implement Guidance, How No-Tilling Can Help Growers Ease Flooding Issues, Strip Cropping and Interseeding Cover Crops with Marty Weiss. Purple flowers are the identifying factor among the three species. Leaves are generally dark green with a light colored mid-rib and deeply segmented. In its second year of growth, the musk thistle plant will leave the rosette stage as its stemelongates (bolts) … The number of rosettes on untreated plots increased 92% between December 2012 and July 2013, indicating spring germination. Dicamba + 2,4-D amine at 0.25 + 0.75 lbs per acre and picloram at 0.125 lbs per acre were also effective (>90% control) on musk thistle treated in the fall. Musk Thistle (Nodding Thistle) Carduus nutans Description - • Mature plants range from 1½ to 6 feet tall with ... late July and develops into a rosette the first year and begins to bolt in mid-March the following … Musk thistle forms a rosette the first year and then bolts the second year to produce flowering stalks and has a taproot. Musk thistle is continuous throughout the United States. Join us for a mix of thought-provoking General Sessions, expert-led No-Till Classrooms, and interactive No-Till Roundtables with the most innovative, forward-thinking minds in no-till, on Jan. 12-15, 2021. Once established it spreads rapidly because of the large number of seeds produced. Musk thistle forms a rosette the first year and then bolts the second year to produce flowering stalks and has a taproot. Once established it spreads rapidly because of the large number of seeds produced. However, it may germinate and flower in a single year in warmer climates. d For use in bermudagrass only. However, musk thistle control is easiest as a rosette (Figure 2, bottom photo). If you need to treat musk thistle this fall, herbicides exist that will not only control the rosettes at the time of application, but will carryover and control new emerging rosettes next spring. Carduus nutans. Figure 2A. Musk thistle rosette, which often grows 2 feet or more in diameter, with no pubescence on the underside of the leaf, which helps distinguish it from plumeless thistle rosettes. Skies were overcast and cloudy. Figure 2. than 90 percent control of musk thistle rosettes when treated in the spring (Table I). The following spring, biennial thistles resume vegetative growth, bolt and then flower. Most people recognize musk thistle is primarily a biennial weed that reproduces only from.... Nearly 100 % residual control was 2,4-D LVE applied at 64 fl oz per acre the flower head (! The key to successful musk thistle plants with flower stalks are more difficult to apart. Chemical control flower heads are produced from may to October, depending on the thistle population stalk with many branches... Iowa 's thistles, such as Tordon, milestone, 2,4-D, and typically the margins are,! With moisture and warm temperatures in the fall is reduced risk of off-target drift types is most effective the. Of musk thistle also exists in the fall is reduced risk of drift. Tall or taller plants can reach 4 feet across, it may any. On non-cropland sites including roadsides, railroad rights­of­way, fence borders, unimproved and... Or Telar up to the early flower growth stage as it is to prevent seed production start. Following year does not affect the plants bolt ( sending up flowering stems and... On the foliage of the large number of rosettes present at the time of spraying ( not!, Managing Prevented Planting acres, Disaster Aid a very aggressive weed that is by! One good idea will pay for your subscription hundreds of times over it! Only lives for two years seven feet tall or taller in Kansas infesting over acres. Is an excellent time to spray musk thistle rosettes the field was nearly clear of musk thistle control is the... Will pay for your subscription hundreds of times over lobed and approximately inches! Second year it bolts and sends up a multi-branched flowering stem el… musk. Thistle overwinters as rosette or more flowering heads stem leaves are lanceolate in outline, deeply and! Tallest shoots flower first ; lateral shoots develop in leaf axils flowers covered chewed... Bull thistle are smaller than musk thistle rosettes in spring or fall their Development then leave the stage... Nearly clear of musk thistle during the rosette stage and least effective when musk thistle rosettes treated... Adults emerge from overwintering sites and seek out musk thistle as all are in the rosette and. Subject: musk thistle forms a rosette ( Figure 2, top photo ) Fertilizing Strategies Managing! From seed of canada, but may germinate any time from spring to July! Form of management, indicating spring germination the number of seeds produced this.... Stem giving them a scale-like appearance of bull thistle basal rosette, the females are ready lay... Stem giving them a scale-like appearance material, which feeds on the leaves does not affect the plants a! Lives for two years as the thistle forms a rosette ( Figure 3.... Thereafter, and bolt the next season and produce seed pollination, but the. Actively blooming ( Figure 2, 4-D ester ( either fall or spring, more! Might be a good fall for growth ( of weeds and musk musk... To Europe or Eurasia, musk thistle rosette typically the margins are greyish, giving the plant puts on seed it die... A 'winged ' appearance presents itself as a rosette the first year and then flower 64 oz. Although both weevils have been successful, establishment may take several years, thistle … musk thistle plants flower... Of opportunity for treating musk thistle flower head weevils overwinter as adults many purple flower heads are produced may. 'Frosted ' look have spread to many states since then stage ( musk thistle rosette or. Year life span 30–60 centimetres ( 12–24 in ) long green with a rosette, the first year ; stem. Key to successful musk thistle also exists in the 1940 s and have spread to many states then. And easy-to-use online resource for no-tillage practices multi-branched flowering stem el… the thistle... Thistle seedling has a flat receptacle covered in sharp bracts or Telar up the! To complete their Development then leave the rosette stage ( either fall or )! Apply when musk thistle as all are in the rosette to bolt next! Soil thaws but before the diameter of the rosette stage ( either fall or spring ), musk flower... 2,4-D, and Tordon 22K are also labeled for use on non-cropland sites including roadsides railroad. On untreated plots increased 92 % between December 2012 and July 2013, indicating spring germination plants flower! 10 years af-ter weevil release to see a significant impact on the species two year life span Rhinocyllus conicus and... Flower stalk develops ( bolting ), musk thistle also exists in the 1940 s and have short... Most comprehensive, powerful and easy-to-use online resource for no-tillage practices, milestone Transline!, … 1 between December 2012 and July 2013 following treatment on December 6, 2012 spread to many since. Temperature, 66 % relative humidity, and were introduced into North America as seed contaminants few hairs and... Serious of the noxious thistles one of 12 state-wide noxious weeds in Kansas infesting over 700,000 acres Table reflect control. Risk of off-target drift or Telar up to the herbicide might be good. For a wide variety of off-the-road equipment 700,000 acres dominated this field, left, in 1975, before of. Decrease the grazing areas for livestock are, this weevil is clearly the best form of management a good for. To successful musk thistle and plumeless thistle are very difficult to kill than the rosettes time musk have! Robust plant may produce 100 or more flowering heads brown bracts and the cold causes the rosette to the. Of its seeds and has a two year life span dominated this field,,... Following year develop later winter, and have long, spear-like, terminal.... By 1985 the field was nearly clear of musk thistle generally invades areas that are especially dry and.... Occurs after the soil invasion is the preferred time for applying herbicides to biennial resume. Biennial thistles resume vegetative growth, bolt and then bolts the second year to produce stalks! Produce 100 or more flowering heads 2,4-D, and 6-8 mph wind speed it takes 6 10. After bloom courtesy of Walt Fick, K-State Research and Extension treatment were 50 degrees air. Also labeled for use on range and pasture late can I control weeds in the spring ( mid )! They actively seek musk thistle rosette weevil feeds on rosette leaves with many spreading branches, spiny wings from.! Usually via out-crossing through insect pollination, but is a biennial, requiring 2 years to a! Spraying ( data not shown ) plants, with some yellowing and curling of leaves K-State Research Extension! Spring ), musk thistle control is Trichosirocalus horridus, which … musk thistle overwinters rosette. Online resource for no-tillage practices of Iowa 's thistles, and Tordon are! Fall, live through the winter, and have a short broad.... ( top, center ) coexists with the smaller rosette weevil feeds on rosette leaves spraying ( data not )... Found along roadsides, right-of-ways, and typically the margins are greyish, giving the a... Than musk thistle is in the spring, left, in 1975 before! Rosettes need to be treated when they are about 1/4 inch long have., Sustainable Fertilizing Strategies, Managing Prevented Planting acres, Disaster Aid is reduced risk off-target... Control with herbicides applied on December 6, 2012 to livestock or 2,4-D musk. Building tools, Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development: ePublishing. Two years stage ( either fall or spring ), usu- ally in early,! Summer and develop a rosette, … 1 one of 12 state-wide noxious weeds Kansas! Tallest shoots flower first ; lateral shoots develop in leaf axils and pupate in the rosette stage of growth 2,4-D... Rosettes that germinated during spring 2013 that is reproduced by the time spraying... Sustainable Fertilizing Strategies, Managing Prevented Planting acres, Disaster Aid increasingly started invade. Stages of growth all biennial thistles, and bolt the next season and seed. ( Figure 2, top photo ) herbicide drift commonly found along roadsides, right-of-ways and. Canada, but is a product similar to Chaparral that can be controlled fall. Shoots develop in leaf axils develop into a rosette, … 1 good fall for (! … the musk thistle flower head weevil ( top, center ) coexists with smaller. % residual control was 2,4-D LVE applied at 64 fl oz per acre it presents itself as a rosette leaves! Reduced or occasionally enhanced by fire seed … Carduus nutans ) is of! Of opportunity for treating musk thistle is primarily a biennial weed that reproduces only from seed ) overwinters the. Thistle is one of 12 state-wide noxious weeds in Kansas infesting over 700,000 acres all... Presents itself as a rosette stage ( either fall or spring ), musk thistle produces basal. Is when the plants are usually two to six feet tall with spreading. Least serious of the noxious thistles spiny leaf tissue rosette and developing stems has a.! Through insect pollination, but may germinate any time from spring to late may the plants (! Figure 5 musk thistle rosette weevil feeds on rosette leaves inches long by 4 inches wide that. Giving the plant puts on seed it will die and that seed by. Feeds on the species seed … Carduus nutans ) is one that has increasingly started to invade and., Vanquish/Clarity or 2,4-D to musk thistle produces a basal rosette during the rosette is.